christiefan915
Catalyst
yurt was a wolf. obviously he would know that nigel wasn't a wolf.
Oooops!!! I forgot about yurt being a wolf when I wrote that.
yurt was a wolf. obviously he would know that nigel wasn't a wolf.
Unless the vigilante has someway of knowing who the wolves are, he's as much a threat to the villagers as he is to the wolves
The village runs as much of a chance as the wolves do, of having the vigilante wiping them out
how much did nigel being a good player also factor into your decision?
we are talking about after a few seer peeks. it's the tandem that makes for a devastating effect.
It was a straight up Seer Hunt. I looked for the odd post, that "sounded" odd and I thought could contain code. I was directly looking for a "hint" inside a post. That all of DH's posts were like this didn't help him out. In retrospect I should have suspected Mott a ton earlier the previous game, those silly poems would scream "Seer" to a wolfpack... that he wasn't killed was absolutely a large sign of Wolf.
Had he posted normally, strong player or not I would have hit at somebody else whose post seemed to include Seer hint.
And Billy had huge huevos to pull that Vigilante kill that night. I thought he was going to go for Yurt though, and Grind had said that if the Wolves and the Vigilante kill were directly against each other the Wolves would win and the Vigilante would be unsuccessful. So, instead of blocking him we went to kill him. That he went after Mott instead was a stroke of pure luck for us. I was hoping we'd get the Vigilante, it was just bonus that he got off a shot at a villager first.
Had he been right, and Mott was a wolf though, it would have been epic. The Vigilante shot still wouldn't have gone. We were almost positive he was the Vigilante due to the posts at the end just before his shot. "Which of these are most wolf"...
Mott was the only logical answer, for us, but I knew he suspected Yurt too... We didn't block him, we blocked our secondary "Vigilante" which was Christie.
With two kills we got both the power roles, and got an extra villager to boot.
It could easily have gone a different direction though, had he been right, and had we not suspected him so heavily, it would have been a game changer.
Mott was the only logical answer, for us, but I knew he suspected Yurt too... We didn't block him, we blocked our secondary "Vigilante" which was Christie.
Just to be clear; we swept and we never used one power.
I have a question now; because your post seems to go against what Darla said, unless you never bothered to tell her what you were going to do!!
Blocking Christie was worthless, she had no power. Basically, it was a moot block. It would be like jumping up on an otherwise empty football field and saying you were blocking a field goal.
I'm not questioning who you blocked, or didn't; but instead the difference in Darla saying your team never used any of the powers and your comment of blocking Chrisite.
Just seemed to be at odds with each other.
You focus on minutiae. None of our powers came to any fruition. It wasn't the powers that gave us any edge. Which is what Darla was saying.
It's bogus to try to play "gotcha" with that. I also "watched" somebody on night one, even though we were pretty sure we were killing the Seer. What if we were wrong? It came to nothing, because we were right.
Basically, all Darla was saying is that any Wolf "power" never gave us any advantage at all.
And if you had more than one shot?SHOOT GRIND
You focus on minutiae. None of our powers came to any fruition. It wasn't the powers that gave us any edge. Which is what Darla was saying.
It's bogus to try to play "gotcha" with that. I also "watched" somebody on night one, even though we were pretty sure we were killing the Seer. What if we were wrong? It came to nothing, because we were right.
Basically, all Darla was saying is that any Wolf "power" never gave us any advantage at all.
For future reference, I think if the Vigilante is going to be over ruled by the Wolves, then he shouldn't be allowed to shoot anyone if the Wolves kill him, be they Wolves, the Seer, Masons, the Angel, or ordinary Villagers.
Also, I just realized that Billy didn't shoot himself, which he used to joke about doing...
I have a question now; because your post seems to go against what Darla said, unless you never bothered to tell her what you were going to do!!
You focus on minutiae. None of our powers came to any fruition. It wasn't the powers that gave us any edge. Which is what Darla was saying.
It's bogus to try to play "gotcha" with that. I also "watched" somebody on night one, even though we were pretty sure we were killing the Seer. What if we were wrong? It came to nothing, because we were right.
Basically, all Darla was saying is that any Wolf "power" never gave us any advantage at all.
i think this round of WW was one of the best we've had.